WayfindersRE/MAX Integrity Leaders
Farmingville, NY 11738 · Town of Brookhaven

Selling a house in Farmingville

Brookhaven Town Hall is in Farmingville, at 1 Independence Hill. The Building Division and the Assessor that a Farmingville sale deals with both work from there, and most Building Division business now runs through an online portal.

Below: what Pete has sold here, what the Town now asks for and where, and how a listing gets priced.

Peter Grosso's record in Farmingville

16

homes sold in Farmingville with Peter Grosso as the listing agent.

First closing
2017
Most recent
October 2026

Source: OneKey MLS closed-sale records. As of November 14, 2026.

Past sales do not guarantee future results, and every home and every market is different. If your home is currently listed with another broker, this is not a solicitation of that listing.

The town's market, not his results

Farmingville right now: every closed sale, all brokers

$650kMedian sale priceAcross 128 closed sales
24Days on marketHalf of them sold faster than this
103.3%Of the first asking priceWhat the typical home actually got
88%Met or beat the askShare of closed sales
22On the market nowYour competition, today
2.1Months of supplyHow long today's inventory would last

Figures are computed from closed-sale records in the licensed listing feed for the last 12 months and refresh through the day. They describe a market, not a property: no statistic here is an appraisal, an automated valuation, or an opinion of value for any individual home. For what a specific home would bring, ask us for a comparative market analysis.

Listings courtesy of OneKey MLS as distributed by MLS GRID

Selling a house in Farmingville: local facts

Each item was read on the Town of Brookhaven's site, the County's map, the Postal Service lookup or New York's published law on the date shown. Follow the link for the current version. This is not legal advice.

  • Farmingville is part of the Town of Brookhaven on Suffolk County's planning map.

    Source: Suffolk County Department of Planning, Town of Brookhaven map. Read November 14, 2026.

  • Brookhaven Town Hall stands in Farmingville, at 1 Independence Hill. The Building Division works from that address, and grievance papers for the Assessor are mailed there.

    Source: Town of Brookhaven, Building Division (contact block); Assessor, Grievance Day page. Read November 14, 2026.

  • ZIP 11738 carries the city name Farmingville in the Postal Service's lookup.

    Source: USPS ZIP Code Lookup, cities by ZIP Code (11738). Read November 14, 2026.

  • Brookhaven's Building Division has moved permits, applications, plan reviews, inspections and payments to the Town's Digital Services portal, and no longer takes drop-offs. If an application filed before September 28, 2026 can't be found, the Town has a help form for it. An owner filing their own residential application can still ask for a paper one at Town Hall, as long as every plan and page fits on 8½-by-11 paper.

    Source: Town of Brookhaven, Building Division. Read November 14, 2026.

  • To set a property's ownership history on record with the Town, Brookhaven takes a Chain of Title application. It calls for a Chain of Title report and a property survey, and the Town charges an application fee.

    Source: Town of Brookhaven, Chain of Title. Read November 14, 2026.

  • Renting out a house in Brookhaven legally takes a House Rental License. A new one is issued only after the house passes an inspection, and it is good for one year. The Town may ask for a survey, floor plans of every rental unit, and the certificate of occupancy, certificate of compliance or building permits. The Town charges an application fee and a license fee.

    Source: Town of Brookhaven, House Rental License. Read November 14, 2026.

  • A Brookhaven tax bill covers December 1 through November 30. Half is due by January 10 and the rest by May 31. An unpaid first half picks up 1% interest a month after January 10, and after May 31 unpaid tax goes to the Suffolk County Comptroller with a 5% penalty.

    Source: Town of Brookhaven, Receiver of Taxes FAQ. Read November 14, 2026.

  • When a one- or two-family house changes hands in New York, the seller gives the buyer an affidavit at closing saying the smoke alarms meet state law. The buyer has ten days to report an alarm that doesn't work, and the seller bears the cost of fixing it.

    Source: New York Executive Law § 378(5-b)(e). Read November 14, 2026.

How a listing starts here

It starts with a comparative market analysis, done by a licensed person, not a website estimate. We look at what Farmingville homes like yours closed for and how long they took, then send the range with the sales attached.

If a permit, a certificate or a rental license is going to come up with a buyer's attorney, it is better found now. We look at what the Town has on file before we talk price.

Free, no obligation

Where's the house?

Street address in Farmingville and how to reach you. A licensed member of the team sends back the analysis. Nothing to sign.

One of the two is enough — whichever you'd rather we use.

No account, no automated valuation, no drip campaign. A licensed person reads this and answers you.

A comparative market analysis is a licensed broker's opinion prepared for your decision. It is not an appraisal and cannot be used as the basis of value for a mortgage.

More on how pricing and marketing work: selling with the team.

Questions from Farmingville owners

The Town moved online. How do I find an old permit application?

Brookhaven's Building Division has a help form for applications filed before September 28, 2026 that you can't find or update in the new Digital Services portal. Someone from the Town follows up.

We rent the house out. What does the Town require?

A House Rental License, issued after an inspection and renewed every year. If the house is sold, the buyer's plans for it decide what happens next; the license is something to have in order before listing.

Who pays the property tax that's due around closing?

That is settled between the attorneys in the contract and at closing. Brookhaven's calendar is the starting point: the first half is due by January 10 and the second by May 31.

How long has Pete been selling in Farmingville?

His first Farmingville closing as listing agent was in July 2017. There have been 16 in all, the latest in October 2026 (OneKey MLS closed-sale records, checked November 14, 2026).

Reach Pete

Peter C. Grosso, Licensed Real Estate Broker, New York #10311207563

The Wayfinders Team at RE/MAX Integrity Leaders
177 West Main Street, Smithtown, NY 11787

Direct: 631-365-3271 · Office: 631-736-2000