WayfindersRE/MAX Integrity Leaders
Middle Island, NY 11953 · Town of Brookhaven

Selling a house in Middle Island

New York's Pine Barrens law uses Yaphank-Middle Island Road as part of the line around its Core Preservation Area. If your land is near that line, what can be built on it may be a State question as well as a Town one.

Here is how the Pine Barrens rules are set up, what Pete has sold in Middle Island, and how to ask what your house would sell for.

Peter Grosso's record in Middle Island

10

homes sold in Middle Island with Peter Grosso as the listing agent.

First closing
2018
Most recent
January 2026

Source: OneKey MLS closed-sale records. As of November 14, 2026.

Past sales do not guarantee future results, and every home and every market is different. If your home is currently listed with another broker, this is not a solicitation of that listing.

The town's market, not his results

Middle Island right now: every closed sale, all brokers

$448kMedian sale priceAcross 215 closed sales
30Days on marketHalf of them sold faster than this
100.0%Of the first asking priceWhat the typical home actually got
62%Met or beat the askShare of closed sales
57On the market nowYour competition, today
3.2Months of supplyHow long today's inventory would last

Figures are computed from closed-sale records in the licensed listing feed for the last 12 months and refresh through the day. They describe a market, not a property: no statistic here is an appraisal, an automated valuation, or an opinion of value for any individual home. For what a specific home would bring, ask us for a comparative market analysis.

Listings courtesy of OneKey MLS as distributed by MLS GRID

Selling a house in Middle Island: local facts

Every item comes from a State, County or Postal Service page, read on the date listed. Click through for the current version. These are facts, not legal advice.

  • Middle Island is in the Town of Brookhaven, between Coram and Ridge on Suffolk County's planning map, with Gordon Heights to the south.

    Source: Suffolk County Department of Planning, Town of Brookhaven map. Read November 15, 2026.

  • ZIP 11953 has one city name in the Postal Service's lookup: Middle Island.

    Source: USPS ZIP Code Lookup, cities by ZIP Code (11953). Read November 15, 2026.

  • Cathedral Pines County Park is on Yaphank-Middle Island Road, south of Route 25. The County describes it as a 320-acre site at the headwaters of the Carmans River, with camping, hiking trails and mountain biking.

    Source: Suffolk County Parks, Cathedral Pines County Park. Read November 15, 2026.

  • The Central Pine Barrens takes in parts of eastern Brookhaven, western Southampton and southern Riverhead. It has two parts: the Core Preservation Area, where new development is prohibited, and the Compatible Growth Area, where limited development that fits the environment is allowed.

    Source: Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning and Policy Commission, FAQs. Read November 15, 2026.

  • Under the Pine Barrens law, work that counts as development is reviewed and work that doesn't is not. The Commission lists exemptions, among them building one single-family home in the Core, and says Town and other approvals may still apply. Its office answers questions at 631-288-1079.

    Source: Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning and Policy Commission, FAQs. Read November 15, 2026.

  • The State law that draws the Core Preservation Area names County Route 21 (Yaphank-Middle Island Road) and the State's Middle Island Game Farm in its boundary description.

    Source: New York Environmental Conservation Law § 57-0107. Read November 15, 2026.

  • Before a listing agreement is signed, New York requires the listing agent to give the seller a written agency disclosure form and ask for a signed acknowledgment.

    Source: New York Real Property Law § 443(3)(a). Read November 15, 2026.

How a listing starts here

Send us the address. A licensed person checks the Middle Island sales that best match your house and returns a comparative market analysis: a range, the closings it is built on, and how we got there.

The first paper you see from us is New York's agency disclosure form. The State has the listing agent hand it over before any listing agreement, so you know whose side the agent is on.

Free, no obligation

Start with the address

Your Middle Island address and a way to reach you. A licensed member of the team sends the analysis. Asking costs nothing.

One of the two is enough — whichever you'd rather we use.

No account, no automated valuation, no drip campaign. A licensed person reads this and answers you.

A comparative market analysis is a licensed broker's opinion prepared for your decision. It is not an appraisal and cannot be used as the basis of value for a mortgage.

More on how pricing and marketing work: selling with the team.

Questions from Middle Island owners

Is my property in the Pine Barrens Core?

That turns on its exact location. The Commission's office answers it at 631-288-1079. Even in the Core, the Commission lists building one single-family home among its exemptions, though Town approvals still apply.

What's the form you ask me to sign before we list?

New York's agency disclosure form. State law has the listing agent give it to you before a listing agreement and ask you to sign that you received it.

Do I need anything from the Town before I call?

No. Send the address and we'll look up what the Town has on file for the house.

How many homes has Pete sold in Middle Island?

Ten as the listing agent, the first in November 2018 and the latest in January 2026 (OneKey MLS closed-sale records, checked November 14, 2026).

Reach Pete

Peter C. Grosso, Licensed Real Estate Broker, New York #10311207563

The Wayfinders Team at RE/MAX Integrity Leaders
177 West Main Street, Smithtown, NY 11787

Direct: 631-365-3271 · Office: 631-736-2000