Selling a house with a tenant in it
In the Towns of Islip, Brookhaven and Smithtown and the Village of Patchogue, the first question on a rented house is the rental permit or registration. Each code makes it unlawful for a broker to list or show a rented home without it.
So the first step is not a price. It is finding out what the Town has on file. Send the address and we check that before anything else.
What the codes say
Read in each Town's and the Village's published code, on the Town of Brookhaven's site and in New York's published law on the date shown. Codes change; the linked page is the authority. This is not legal advice.
Town of Islip: a home, or an apartment in it, may not be rented to anyone but the owner without a rental occupancy permit from the Town. The permit does not pass to a buyer. A new owner who keeps renting registers within 30 days of closing.
Source: Code of the Town of Islip, Chapter 68, Article L, § 68-650. Read November 14, 2026.
Town of Islip: it is unlawful for a broker or agent to list or show for sale a dwelling that is rented, or has a rented unit in it, unless a current rental occupancy permit has been issued. Verifying the permit is the broker's duty.
Source: Code of the Town of Islip, Chapter 68, Article L, § 68-662. Read November 15, 2026.
Town of Brookhaven: it is unlawful for a broker or agent to list, advertise or show for sale a dwelling unit for which a current rental permit has not been issued.
Source: Town of Brookhaven Code, Chapter 82, § 82-12. Read November 15, 2026.
Town of Brookhaven: the code gives a defense when the people living in the unit are the owner's immediate family, as the code defines that term.
Source: Town of Brookhaven Code, Chapter 82, § 82-10. Read November 15, 2026.
Town of Brookhaven: a House Rental License is issued only after the house passes an inspection, and it runs for one year. The Town may ask for a survey, floor plans of each rental unit, and the certificate of occupancy or building permits.
Source: Town of Brookhaven, House Rental License. Read November 14, 2026.
Town of Smithtown: the code says no person, real estate broker or agent shall list, show or occupy any home that has not been registered with the Town. It also requires a house to be rented in its entirety as one dwelling, not partitioned into separate apartments.
Source: Code of the Town of Smithtown, rental property registry. Read November 15, 2026.
Village of Patchogue: it is unlawful for a broker or agent to list, advertise or show a residence as having a rental unit unless a current Village rental occupancy permit is in force. Verifying the permit before acting for the owner is the broker's duty. A Village permit runs two years.
Source: Code of the Village of Patchogue, Chapter 336, Rental Property. Read November 15, 2026.
New York State: a landlord who does not intend to renew a residential tenancy has to give the tenant written notice, and the statute sets how much.
Source: New York Real Property Law § 226-c. Read November 15, 2026.
How a sale starts when the house is rented
- We look up what the Town has on file for the address: a rental permit or license, the certificate of occupancy, any open permits.
- If the permit is current, the house can be listed with the tenant living there.
- If there is no permit or registration, we tell you plainly. The code bars a broker from listing or showing the house until there is one. Whether to apply for it or wait until the unit is empty is a decision for you and your attorney.
- Then the price: a comparative market analysis prepared by a licensed person from recorded sales.
Start with the address
Questions owners ask
The apartment was never made legal. Do I have to say so?
Say it early. The Town's records show what is on file, and a buyer's attorney will ask for them. Knowing at the start gives you and your attorney time to decide what to do.
My tenant is a relative. Does the rental rule apply?
Brookhaven's code gives a defense when the people living there are the owner's immediate family, as the code defines it. Islip's code is written differently. Your attorney can tell you how either one applies to you.
Can I sell with the tenant staying?
Often, if the rental permit is current. In Islip the permit does not pass to the buyer: a new owner who keeps renting registers within 30 days of closing. What happens to the lease is a question for the attorneys.
I want the house empty before I sell. What notice does the tenant get?
New York requires written notice when a landlord does not intend to renew a residential tenancy, and the statute sets how much. Talk to your attorney before you say anything to the tenant.
My house is in a different Town or Village. Is it the same?
Not necessarily. Each Town and Village on Long Island writes its own rental rules, and four of them are set out above. Send the address and we check the one your house is in.
Reach Pete
Peter C. Grosso, Licensed Real Estate Broker, New York #10311207563
The Wayfinders Team at RE/MAX Integrity Leaders
177 West Main Street, Smithtown, NY 11787
Direct: 631-365-3271 · Office: 631-736-2000