WayfindersRE/MAX Integrity Leaders
Holbrook, NY 11741 · Town of Islip

Selling a house in Holbrook

Holbrook is in the Town of Islip, in its northeast corner, and the Brookhaven line runs right along its edge. Islip and Brookhaven run their rental permits on different clocks, so a rented house here starts with one question: is the permit current?

Below are Pete's Holbrook numbers, the Islip rules a sale here runs into, and the way to ask for a price analysis.

Peter Grosso's record in Holbrook

13

homes sold in Holbrook with Peter Grosso as the listing agent.

First closing
2017
Most recent
December 2023

Source: OneKey MLS closed-sale records. As of November 14, 2026.

Past sales do not guarantee future results, and every home and every market is different. If your home is currently listed with another broker, this is not a solicitation of that listing.

The town's market, not his results

Holbrook right now: every closed sale, all brokers

$685kMedian sale priceAcross 206 closed sales
18.5Days on marketHalf of them sold faster than this
103.6%Of the first asking priceWhat the typical home actually got
78%Met or beat the askShare of closed sales
28On the market nowYour competition, today
1.6Months of supplyHow long today's inventory would last

Figures are computed from closed-sale records in the licensed listing feed for the last 12 months and refresh through the day. They describe a market, not a property: no statistic here is an appraisal, an automated valuation, or an opinion of value for any individual home. For what a specific home would bring, ask us for a comparative market analysis.

Listings courtesy of OneKey MLS as distributed by MLS GRID

Selling a house in Holbrook: local facts

Read on the County's maps, the Town of Islip's code and tax office pages, the Postal Service lookup and Brookhaven's code on the date shown. Follow the link for the current wording. None of this is legal advice.

How a listing starts here

Give us the address. A licensed person on the team studies recent Holbrook closings like your house and sends a comparative market analysis: where the price should sit, the sales that support it, and the thinking behind it.

If there's a tenant, we look at the rental permit's date first. Islip's code makes a current permit the broker's job to confirm before a rented house is listed or shown.

Free, no obligation

The Holbrook address

Address, plus a number or email. If part of the house is rented, mention when the permit runs out. A licensed person answers with the analysis.

One of the two is enough — whichever you'd rather we use.

No account, no automated valuation, no drip campaign. A licensed person reads this and answers you.

A comparative market analysis is a licensed broker's opinion prepared for your decision. It is not an appraisal and cannot be used as the basis of value for a mortgage.

More on how pricing and marketing work: selling with the team.

Questions from Holbrook owners

Our Islip rental permit runs out in the spring. Should we renew before listing?

Islip permits last two years, and the renewal is due at least 60 days before the old one expires. A broker can't list or show a rented house without a current permit, so check the date before anything else.

There's a gas boiler and a tenant upstairs. What does Islip require?

Its rental code calls for a carbon monoxide alarm next to every bedroom in a rental with a fuel-burning appliance, with battery backup if it's electric.

Is a Holbrook house on Islip's tax bill or Brookhaven's?

The Town the lot is in sends the bill. For Islip, the first half is due January 10 and the second May 31, with a penalty that climbs a point a month after January 10. Send the address and we'll confirm the Town.

What's Pete's history in Holbrook?

Thirteen closed sales as the listing agent. The first was in August 2017 and the latest in December 2023, according to OneKey MLS closed-sale records checked November 14, 2026.

Reach Pete

Peter C. Grosso, Licensed Real Estate Broker, New York #10311207563

The Wayfinders Team at RE/MAX Integrity Leaders
177 West Main Street, Smithtown, NY 11787

Direct: 631-365-3271 · Office: 631-736-2000