Selling a house in Shirley
Shirley reaches the bay on Brookhaven's south shore, so flooding is part of the paperwork on a sale here. New York's disclosure form asks the seller about flood zones, flood insurance and past flood claims, and FEMA's map answers the first of those for any address.
Both are laid out below with links, with Pete's Shirley record and how to get a price on your house.
Peter Grosso's record in Shirley
8
homes sold in Shirley with Peter Grosso as the listing agent.
- First closing
- 2019
- Most recent
- October 2026
Source: OneKey MLS closed-sale records. As of November 14, 2026.
Past sales do not guarantee future results, and every home and every market is different. If your home is currently listed with another broker, this is not a solicitation of that listing.
Shirley right now: every closed sale, all brokers
Figures are computed from closed-sale records in the licensed listing feed for the last 12 months and refresh through the day. They describe a market, not a property: no statistic here is an appraisal, an automated valuation, or an opinion of value for any individual home. For what a specific home would bring, ask us for a comparative market analysis.
Selling a house in Shirley: local facts
Each item comes from a federal, State or County page, or the Postal Service, read on the date shown. Click through for the current version. Nothing here is legal advice.
Suffolk County's planning map puts Shirley on the Town of Brookhaven's south shore, across the bay from Fire Island. The map draws no village line inside it.
Source: Suffolk County Department of Planning, Town of Brookhaven map. Read November 15, 2026.
The Postal Service's recommended city name for ZIP 11967 is Shirley. It also recognizes East Yaphank and Smith Point for addresses at that ZIP.
Source: USPS ZIP Code Lookup, cities by ZIP Code (11967). Read November 15, 2026.
New York's Property Condition Disclosure Statement asks the seller whether any of the property is in a FEMA floodplain or Special Flood Hazard Area, whether federal law requires flood insurance on it, whether it has flood insurance or a FEMA elevation certificate, whether the seller ever filed a flood damage claim, and whether the seller or a past owner got FEMA help for flood damage.
Source: New York Real Property Law § 462(2), questions 10 to 17. Read November 15, 2026.
FEMA's Flood Map Service Center is the official public source for flood hazard information under the National Flood Insurance Program. It looks up the official flood map for an address, a place name or coordinates.
Source: FEMA Flood Map Service Center. Read November 15, 2026.
When construction began in January 2022, the State described the Forge River Watershed Sewer District as serving nearly 1,900 parcels in the Mastic-Shirley area, from just west of William Floyd Parkway east to the Forge River. It moves them off cesspools and septic systems to a sewer line and a new treatment plant in Mastic.
Source: Office of the Governor of New York, Forge River sewer groundbreaking, January 27, 2022. Read November 15, 2026.
Smith Point County Park's address is 1 William Floyd Parkway, Shirley. The County's directions are to take William Floyd Parkway south to its end at Fire Island. The park lists beaches, camping and outer-beach access.
Source: Suffolk County Parks, Smith Point County Park. Read November 15, 2026.
The Wertheim National Wildlife Refuge is at 340 Smith Road in Shirley. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service says it protects 2,550 acres on the south shore and is split by the Carmans River, a State-designated scenic river. Its trails are open from sunrise to sunset.
Source: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Wertheim National Wildlife Refuge. Read November 15, 2026.
How a listing starts here
It starts with the address. A licensed member of the team weighs your house against recent Shirley closings and sends a comparative market analysis: the range, the sales, and the reasons.
We also pull the FEMA flood map for the lot before talking price. The disclosure form asks about it and a buyer will look too, so it helps to know first.
More on how pricing and marketing work: selling with the team.
Questions from Shirley owners
Do I have to tell a buyer the house is in a flood zone?
New York's Property Condition Disclosure Statement asks it directly, along with whether there's flood insurance, a FEMA elevation certificate, a past flood claim or FEMA flood help. The form reaches the buyer before a contract is signed.
How do I find out if my lot is in a flood zone?
FEMA's Flood Map Service Center looks it up by address. It is the official public source of flood maps for the National Flood Insurance Program.
Is the house on the new sewer?
As the State described it at the 2022 groundbreaking, the Forge River sewer district covers part of the Mastic-Shirley area, from just west of William Floyd Parkway east to the Forge River. Whether a given lot is in it turns on the address, so send it and we'll check.
Has Pete sold in Shirley?
Yes, eight homes as the listing agent, from July 2019 through October 2026, by OneKey MLS closed-sale records checked November 14, 2026.
Reach Pete
Peter C. Grosso, Licensed Real Estate Broker, New York #10311207563
The Wayfinders Team at RE/MAX Integrity Leaders
177 West Main Street, Smithtown, NY 11787
Direct: 631-365-3271 · Office: 631-736-2000